Update: Stein's Withdraws Proposal for Seasonal Garden Center
On Tuesday, Plan Commission approved Stein's revised proposal, which costs about $18,000 less by replacing pavement with wood chips.
Updated 11 p.m. Friday: After the Plan Commission meeting, Stein's notified the village that the company is withdrawing its proposal and will site the business in another community, according to Village Manager Patrick DeGrave's weekly memo.
Whitefish Bay trustees did not want to spend nearly $55,000 on a paved "events pad" in the parking lot behind Fitzgerald's Pharmacy, but now that the price tag has been cut to $37,000, Plan Commissioners are recommending the Village Board give the concept final approval.
The concept of an "events pad" was created to allow a space for a seasonal Stein's Garden Center, Stein's Just Plants, and other vendors to use the space without taking up parking in the lot between Silver Spring Drive and Beaumont Avenue. The original proposal called for paving over the north end of the parking lot median near Beaumont, but due to the nearly $55,000 price tag, trustees floated the idea of using wood chips instead of pavement to cut costs. Stein's agreed to the idea.
As rent, Stein's has agreed to pay the village $15,000 and donate 500 pumpkins to the village's Great Pumpkin Display. Village Manager Patrick DeGrave said no other tenants are confirmed to use the events pad, and any civic groups that use the pad would not be charged rent.
To make the project pay off, therefore, Stein's would have to agree to stay at least three summers in Whitefish Bay.
A representative from Stein's at Tuesday morning's Plan Commission meeting said the company would initially like to try the first year, and if it is profitable, continue the business at that location.
Commissioners unanimously voted to recommend the Village Board move forward with drafting a lease with Stein's for next summer. The commissioners maintained their earlier suggestions that the board take into consideration the costs and benefits, low-impact lighting, parking, safety and the possibility of using pervious pavement to reduce stormwater runoff when drafting the lease.
Bob McBride
9:19 am on Saturday, December 24, 2011
I assume this is because the village wouldn't cave on the 3 year agreement to cover the cost of the event pad. Good for them.
Kevin Buckley
3:10 pm on Saturday, December 24, 2011
Not sure where you got the idea about a 3 year agreement .. at $55k it would have taken 3 years to break even, yes. To my knowledge, Steins never asked for more than a one year lease, and the Board stuck with one year, to see how things went. As for Sendik's counting this as a "big win"? I don't recall them making their mortgage on selling a few bags of soil in the spring. Maybe Bayside Garden Center will consider this a win.
In any event, I count this up as a loss. Steins would have been a good merchant, and I think a ton of residents would have found the store to be a quality amenity for those 6 weeks. It wasn't perfect, but many, including the BID, supported this effort and wished it could have worked out.
Bob McBride
9:09 pm on Saturday, December 24, 2011
I got the three year agreement thing from the article above, Kevin:
"To make the project pay off, therefore, Stein's would have to agree to stay at least three summers in Whitefish Bay."
Since the update didn't indicate why the deal fell through, I was assuming it was due the insistence on the part of the Village that a 3 year agreement be made before proceeding with the project.
If that's not the case, any idea what happened?